2005: Hampden-Sydney received a gift when the NCAA ruled in favor of allowing Hillmann to play in 2005 due to a medical waiver for the 2004 season.

2004: Played mostly injured in only nine games.

2003: Started all 16 games in which he played.  Hillmann earned his third consecutive All-ODAC selection.  Hillmann was also selected to the NSCAA/Adidas All South Region team.

2002: As a sophomore, Hillmann played in 19 of 20 games, while scoring 10 points on three goals and one assist.